tannenbaum居眠り日記💤

シロート観戦者による、おもに自転車(おもにシクロクロス)関連のすみっこネタブログです。

無線にかんする会話

以下は、6日朝おきたらHTCのマルコ・ピノッティとジャーナリストのシェーン・ストークスとのやりとりが目に付いたので彼らの意見についてはコメント保留でとりあえず貼っておく。

Before World tour calendar starts, who is in favor of radio ban, did you really noticed a change in race tactics or outcomes ?less than a minute ago via Twitter for Android

The race is done by riders, with their legs and heads. Not team director from the car. Just my 2 centsless than a minute ago via Twitter for Android

@marcopinotti Marco, do you favour radio information going from organisers to the riders for safety announcements?less than a minute ago via Echofon

@marcopinotti or do you mean that radios should be allowed, and that they don't influence tactics?less than a minute ago via Echofon

@SSbike even if I perdonally like it w/o radios I'm for the second one. Radio from organizers won't let you repair from bad luckless than a minute ago via Twitter for Android

@SSbike no change in tactics, but bad luck in wrong moment & u can say adios to your chances. Even if I reckon this is part of the gameless than a minute ago via Twitter for Android

@SSbike anyway I am just saying I see no real changes, so I don't see the point of fighting on this issue. Or do u think it changed smthing?less than a minute ago via Twitter for Android

@marcopinotti not sure- you'll know better if it has or hasn't! I could understand the reason why the UCI said they wanted to change itless than a minute ago via Echofon

@marcopinotti but of course they have to be able to show it does have the desired effect. I don't like the way it has been done, and thatless than a minute ago via Echofon

@marcopinotti no alternatives have been publicly considered to protect riders (one way radios, radio Tour, etc). No wonder there areless than a minute ago via Echofon

@marcopinotti protests and people unhappy. For me, total radio ban has more negative than positive consequencesless than a minute ago via Echofon

ピノッティ先生:無線を禁止してもレース戦略は変らない.もともとレースは監督たちではなく選手の足と頭でやるもの。重要な局面でのトラブルはオフィシャルからの一方的な無線連絡ではとりもどせないと思う。無線禁止で特になにも変ってないので論争するポイントが見えない。
Storkes氏:UCIは狙いが効果をあげていることを示す必要がある、これまでのやり方は好ましいと思わない。全面禁止する以外の代替案について正式に検討されていない。全面禁止はメリットよりデメリットが大きいように思う